Closed — final outcome reached

Illinois Clemency Under the State's Postpartum Sentencing Law

👤 Paula Sims 📍 Alton / Brighton, Illinois, USA 🗓 1989 ⚖️ First-degree murder

Case summary

Sims's daughters died three years apart — 13-day-old Loralei in 1986 and six-week-old Heather in 1989 — and in both cases she reported that masked intruders had taken the baby. She was convicted in 1990 of the first-degree murder of Heather and sentenced to life without parole. Illinois' Public Act 100-0574, effective June 1, 2018, made postpartum depression and psychosis a mitigating factor at sentencing and allowed women already serving long sentences to seek resentencing; Sims was among roughly twenty Illinois women identified as potentially eligible. In March 2021 Governor JB Pritzker commuted her sentence to life with the possibility of parole, and in October 2021 the Illinois Prisoner Review Board voted 12-1 to release her from Logan Correctional Center after more than 30 years.

Mental-health context

Postpartum psychosis was never presented to the jury; at trial the only reference to her mental health came when the prosecutor asked whether she had ever suffered from postpartum depression. Her attorney argued for decades that she had been in the grip of postpartum psychosis, and used Illinois' 2018 law recognising postpartum mental illness as a mitigating and post-conviction sentencing factor to press for her release.

Status / outcome

Convicted 1990, life without parole; sentence commuted by executive clemency March 2021; paroled October 2021

Sources

This summary is compiled from public reporting. Allegations are not findings of fact, and every accused person is presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty.

Support thread

Share messages of support, verified information, or helpful resources. Please keep the thread respectful of everyone touched by this case — including victims and families.

No messages yet — be the first to show your support.